Free Compliments of our Advertisers
Sonoma County Gazette

Santa Rosa Veterans Village is Completed

Feb 28, 2019
by Will Carruthers


In late February, local veterans experiencing homelessness finally moved into their new homes, a group of 14 small houses located on county-owned land in north Santa Rosa.

The lot, located on the county’s administrative campus, is the location of Veterans Village, a group of tiny houses intended to house veterans receiving federal benefits.

There are approximately 200 veterans living without shelter in the county, out of the total estimated homeless population of nearly 3,000, according to the county’s 2018 point-in-time count of people experiencing homelessness.

The project, developed by Community Housing Sonoma County (CHSC) and championed by District 1 Supervisor Shirlee Zane, was created to fulfill a county pilot program proposed in 2015 to study the process of developing “non-standard” housing to address the homeless housing crisis.

The project was widely celebrated during an unveiling event in December 2018, despite some development delays and cost increases during the process.

“I never lost faith that we could do this because my father, John Zane, a WWII Marine Veteran who was awarded the Distinguished Flying Cross, taught me something about tenacity. Never, never forget the sacrifices military veterans have made to protect our freedoms," Zane said in December.

Now that Veterans Village is complete, Zane says the county will use the project to inform its work on an ordinance legalizing tiny homes in the county, a model which Zane hopes will be copied throughout the state.

Veterans Village Plan

Tiny Homes

Each home at Veterans Village cost $133,000. The project, which was initially budgeted for $1 million, cost $1.8 million primarily due to increased labor costs after the 2017 fires and unexpected difficulty lining up land for the project, CHSC Executive Director Paula Cook said at a May 8, 2018 Board of Supervisors meeting.

Despite the increased cost, the units still only cost a fraction the price of a conventional affordable housing unit, according to Cook.

One recent study from the Government Accountability Office estimated that the median cost of an affordable housing unit in California was $326,000 in 2015. Other studies put the figure higher.

Veterans Village residents, who are picked from a wait list of veterans receiving federal housing vouchers, will have access to two Veterans Affairs case managers living on site, according to Zane.

“It’s always cost-effective to house people,” given the cost of medical and emergency services accrued by people living on the streets, Zane said in an interview in February.

Veterans Village also features native plants, fruit trees and rain catchments designed to make the project sustainable. Once solar panels are installed, the homes will be zero net energy, according to Cook.

Pilot Program

Tiny Home Floor PlanThe idea of Veterans’ Village was first approved in July 2015 as part of a county pilot program for tiny homes, called the Pilot Project to Use Non-Traditional Structures to Safely Shelter Homeless People.

The pilot project is meant to act as a “trial run” of the concept to allow County staff to determine “what changes to county or state codes will be necessary to allow duplication of the pilot on private sites countywide, potentially leading to statewide duplication,” according to a June 2016 staff report about Veterans Village.

“While there have been a number of ‘tiny home village’ in other states, California’s building and land use laws seemingly prevent some of the innovative models from being carried out legally in California. Sonoma County has the unique opportunity to lead in this area by providing a pilot demonstration project,” the report continues.

Cook also hopes the pilot program will prove effective in laying the groundwork for future tiny home projects on public land.

“It would be nice to utilize what we’ve learned through this process [working on the pilot project] to help house homeless veterans here and around the country,” Cook said.

The Wider Conversation

The completion of Veterans Village is the latest event in an on-going discussion about how the county should spend its limited resources on efforts to shelter the homeless.

Sonoma County has the third-largest homeless population of any mostly-suburban county in the country last year, according to a federal housing report.

In its response to the crisis, the county has adopted a Housing First policy, a method that calls for offering a package of housing and social services to people living on the streets in the hopes of stabilizing their lives and keeping them housed for a long time.

The model was proposed as an alternative to providing permanent housing only after certain prerequisites – such as completing a treatment program - are met by a person experiencing homelessness.

While some activists support quick and inexpensive groupings of tiny homes, safe parking programs and the legalization of pre-existing homeless encampments, Zane favors permanent supportive housing projects, which are traditionally more expensive and more time-intensive to build.

"Nobody is going to be happy about an encampment in their neighborhood," Zane told the North Bay Bohemian in 2015, "and I think we should put our funding into permanent solutions."

With the completion of Veterans Village, Zane stands by her position, saying in a February interview that the encampments only help to perpetuate homelessness, while permanent supportive housing developments like Veterans Village are more likely to keep people off the streets in the long term.


Mar 12, 2019
VIA EMAIL: I applaud the new veteran's village in Santa Rosa (Home at Last, March 2019) that now houses 14 formerly homeless vets. It's a good step in the right direction but the current situation begs clarification on a number of critical issues. First, given the severity of the homeless emergency crisis here in Sonoma County (3,000 people experiencing homelessness) the expenditure of $1.9 million to service 14 seems excessive and leaves the remaining 2,986 human beings out in the cold. The cost of $133,000 per unit compares favorably with costs for standard housing here but falls flat given that far less expensive options are available to us. According to formal proposals based on detailed analysis and submitted to the new County Continuum of Care entity (Home Sonoma) by Homeless Action! it is, in fact, possible to bring respite to around 600 people for two years for only $5 million. Such a plan includes safe parking for cars and RV's as well as a variety of sanctioned tiny home village options with hygiene, security, trash collection, case management, and wraparound services, a far cry from the unsanctioned, unmanaged encampments of old. In addition, such villages can be either transitional or permanent supportive housing. According to Scott Wagner, who has spearheaded such proposals, tiny homes with insulation, windows, heat, lights, lofts, fold-down desks, and lockable doors can be built for around $6,000 each. Central kitchens and bathhouses service the community. Meanwhile, people living on the streets are still systematically subjected to police persecution and confiscation of their tents, sleeping bags, clothing, and other possessions. Their human rights and civil rights are trampled on a daily basis. They have no legal place to sleep and suffer grave physical and emotional consequences as a result. Our societal failure to ensure the well being of this vulnerable population cannot be overstated. Social scientists are alarmed by an accelerating medical crisis among the homeless as a direct result of our shortcomings. In the United States, the average life expectancy in the homeless population is 42-52 years compared with 78 years for the general population. Because they are forced to live without basic hygienic needs and other life-sustaining health necessities, serious infectious epidemics are breaking out among homeless people throughout California, including typhus, Hepatitis A, MERSA, shigella, trench fever, pneumonia and syphilis. Health providers say that because police constantly break up small encampments, people scatter and can't be found in order to receive appropriate medical help. Not surprisingly, emotional disabilities run rampant and for the same reasons cannot be properly administered to. In comparison, a village context allows for centralized case management and appropriate medical attention for the entire community. Given the shortage of funding and housing stock, it's obvious that we need to get the biggest bang for the buck by taking care of the greatest numbers as quickly as possible. Therefore, a $12 million windfall in new state funding for the homeless pales in the face of the fact that were we to try to accommodate the remaining 2,986 people at the rate of $133,000 per unit, it will take $397,000,000 to house the current population! There are 1,000 emergency shelter beds in the county but they're available only for temporary short-term stays. As a consequence, when the Gazette reports Supervisor Shirlee Zane as saying that housing projects such as the Santa Rosa Veterans Village “are more likely to keep people off the streets in the long term,” there seems to be an abysmal disconnect from reality. How can we fail to recognize that until that happy day in the far distant future, nearly 3,000 people are already relegated to lives of perpetual misery for the long term and their prospects in this lifetime are very bleak indeed. Kathleen Finigan, Santa Rosa
- Vesta Copestakes

Login to Make a Comment

Please support our sponsors:

Your Pets Market in Sebastopol and Cotati, Sonoma County, CA
Cloverdale Performing Arts Center - Of Mice and Men

5/4,5,11,12,18,19. Mild adult themes.
Students $12 - Adults $25.
707-894-3222, or at the door if available.

Fine Tree Care - Sonoma County Tree Services

Visit Fine Tree Care WEBSITE for a List of our SERVICES - Testimonials and to request a FREE Estimate

Your GUIDE to support locally-owned garden businesses and natural landscaping practices.

Locally-Owned Jewelry Businesses in Sonoma County

Find Goldsmiths and Jewelers who create custom designs, offer jewelry repair, estate appraisals, and gems.

Flower Shops and Florists of Sonoma County

Please support locally-owned businesses and tell them the Gazette sent you - THANK YOU!