Free Compliments of our Advertisers
Sonoma County Gazette
Abby Brewster (Karen Brocker) and Martha Brewster (Karen Pinomaki) decide on the next gentleman who is deserving of their special kind of charity.

Review – ‘Arsenic and Old Lace’ at Sonoma Arts Live

Feb 1, 2019
by Alexa Chipman


What dark secrets could two polite Edwardian ladies with teacakes possibly have? Surrounded by dainty lace tablecloths and floral arrangements, the Brewster sisters have quietly been stacking up murder victims in their cellar for years. Their nephew, Mortimer, discovers a body in the window seat, which sends him into hysterics, sparking an eccentric comedy that has entranced audiences since 1941. Revived for Sonoma Arts Live’s season of“A Toast to the Classics,” this vintage romp holds up remarkably well, other than an unfortunate flavoring of racially insensitive comments.

Teddy Brewster (Tim Setzer) agrees to dig in Panama at the behest of Abby Brewster (Karen Brocker) and Martha Brewster (Karen Pinomaki).This remarkable cast embodies their quirky characters with fierce intensity, such as Tim Setzer’s Teddy, who believes himself to be President Roosevelt. He charges up the staircase like San Juan Hill, and firmly insists that the cellar is actually Panama.

The less charming sibling, Jonathan, prowls through scenes with brooding malice, portrayed by Mike Schaeffer with suitably disturbing monster makeup by Erik Weiss. Jonathan’s partner in crime, the obsequious Dr. Einstein, is fascinating to watch. Rose Roberts gives a brilliant performance in the role, her expressive eyes darting about.

Elaine Harper (Julianne Bradbury) and Mortimer Brewster (Michael Coury Murdock) share a romantic encounter before attending the theater.

The heart of ‘Arsenic and Old Lace’ is the Brewster sisters and their sweet-natured hospitality. Abby (Karen Brocker) and Martha (Karen Pinomaki) cannot understand why their charity of poisoning lonely men is out of the ordinary, and their innocent sincerity is what makes the characters so likeable, despite being serial killers. Director Michael Ross has created such a believable group of outlandish characters that level-headed Mortimer seems odd in comparison.

In the midst of unwanted revelations, Mortimer and his fiancé Elaine (Julianne Bradbury) are struggling to be honest with each other. Bradbury’s passionate, direct approach to the character gives Elaine a contemporary confidence and poise.

Michael Walraven’s scenic design and  Janis Snyder’s costumes maintain an elegant black and white palette, with occasional touches of burgundy. Gothic sensibilities add unnerving undertones to the Brewster residence, along with well-placed sound design by Jess Johnson during emotionally charged moments.


Officer Brophy (Owen Hardisty) and Officer Klein (Miles Ainley) attempt to hold the dangerous Jonathan Brewster (Mike Schaeffer).

‘Arsenic and Old Lace’ is a suspenseful comedy with delightful absurdity and a superb ensemble. It deserves a congratulatory toast of poison-free elderberry wine.

Arsenic and Old Lace
Presented by Sonoma Arts Live through February 10, 2019
Thur/Fri/Sat at 7:30pm, Sun at 2:00pm
Tickets: $28-40

Sonoma Arts Live
Rotary Stage in Andrews Hall 
Sonoma Community Center
276 East Napa Street, Sonoma, CA 95476
(866) 710-8942

Photos by Miller Oberlin Photography

Author Website -

Travel Blog -
Twitter / Instagram / Facebook - alexachipman
Alexa Chipman Theater reviews


Login to Make a Comment

Please support our sponsors:

Local Guide for takeout food

Sonoma County Restaurants who offer Take-Out Food during the Corona Virus Shelter-in-Place.
NOT on our LIST & MAP? Get LISTED:

Shelter-in-Place Sonoma County Business Directory - Coronavirus-COVID-19 Mandate.

Shelter-in-Place Sonoma County Business Directory - Coronavirus-COVID-19 Mandate. This is a work-in-process. PLEASE HELP US by sending missing info to

Fine Tree Care - Sonoma County Tree Services

Visit Fine Tree Care WEBSITE for a List of our SERVICES - Testimonials and to request a FREE Estimate

Flip through the pages of the print edition of the 2020 Sonoma County Gardeners Resource Guide

Your 2020 GUIDE to support locally-owned garden businesses and natural landscaping practices.

LOCAL GUIDE to Cannabis Dispensaries and Delivery Services, Sonoma County & Beyond.

LOCAL GUIDE to Cannabis Dispensaries and Delivery Services, Sonoma County & Beyond.All dispensaries have verified their information.