Dec 7, 2019
By Eric Koenigshoffer
We have all been to places which are magnificent in their natural splendor but are so congested with people who love them that the experience is degraded along with the natural environment. In this case we are talking about the Sonoma County Coastline which stretches from Marin to Mendocino.
As the process of updating the Local Coastal Plan unfolds (and soon also the county General Plan update) the foundation of analysis should be an understanding of the carrying capacity of the natural environment and man-made infrastructure. Focusing for the moment on the latter, what is the carrying capacity of the roads, water systems/wells, the septic systems and sewerage treatment plants which constitute the core elements of infrastructure supporting human habitation of the area.
And beyond the infrastructure required for those who live on the coast it is critically important to understand the infrastructure demands and impacts of those who visit the coast. The interests of these two groups can and do conflict from time to time.
Carrying capacity is all about understanding limits. The limits of man-made infrastructure and the limits of the natural environment. Good planning is all about staying within those limits. In the Coastal Zone good planning also means balancing statewide policy interests with the quality-of-life and community character interests of those who live on our coast.
For example, an infrastructure limitation we have all experienced is worsening traffic throughout our county and region. Thinking of the coast, how many cars can Hwy One handle at peak season? And how about the roads which lead to the coast through Petaluma, Sebastopol and Guerneville? It doesn’t matter from which direction you come; you will be travelling on a two lane most often narrow rural road.
In the case of all man-made infrastructure the most important point is that it is limited. Exceeding the limits is sure to degrade the natural environment or quality of life or, most likely, both.
Both groups impact infrastructure and the natural environment. However, it is the visitor category which grows and results in the greatest strain on infrastructure. There are millions more visitors to the coast than there are residents…we all know this. While it is recognized that tourism is a central part of the coastal economy there is little consideration of the issue of tourism carrying capacity in the long term. This basic issue underlies most if not all the policy discussion found within the Draft LCP.
Getting a handle on the issues surrounding growth in tourism must be a key aspect of the update process. It is easy for folks to understand highly visible growth such as a new subdivision or a major hotel but it is not so clear when growth comes in the form of increased day visitors coming out to enjoy expanded recreational facilities such as trails, regional parks and major events. No judgment intended as to the value of such activities, but impacts are impacts and planning must treat increased impacts with care.
The fiction of sustainability: It is popular today to frame all manner of human activities as being sustainable. Webster’s dictionary tells us sustainable means “Of, or relating to, or being a method of using a resource so that the resource is not depleted or permanently damaged.”
As we ponder the future of the coast in this LCP update it will be important to take a hard look at the cumulative impacts resulting from increased use of the coast, including those developments we take for granted as being desirable. For more than a century the Sonoma Coast has been a refuge for people living in the Bay Area and the Sacramento Valley. This is certainly still the case. Growth in the Bay Area and especially the Highway 80 corridor to Sacramento generates large increases in visitor days to the Sonoma Coast. In addition to this natural “local” growth in visitors there is a constant, ambitious government funded push to generate more visitors from afar.
I hope to explore this question in greater depth in a future issue.
The agendas for the Public Review Draft workshops are now available within the online calendar events.
The workshops will each include a staff presentation on the draft and time dedicated to discussion and taking public input. The Staff presentation provided at The Sea Ranch on November 17, 2019 (PDF) is available for reference.
Bodega Bay December 14, 2019 10 AM -12 PM
Bodega Bay Fire Station 510 State Hwy 1 Bodega Bay
Welcome Staff Presentation (30 Minutes)
Project timeline and process
What is a Local Coastal Plan?
Purpose of the Local Coastal Plan Update
2015 Preliminary Draft - Review
Public Review Draft Public Comment/Questions (60 Minutes)
Closing Statements (10 Minutes)
Recap and next steps
As requested we are currently developing a location on the project webpage for posting of public comment and summary notes. An additional notice will be sent when public comments are available for review.
Please support our sponsors:
LOCAL GUIDE to Cannabis Dispensaries and Delivery Services, Sonoma County & Beyond.All dispensaries have verified their information.
Find Goldsmiths and Jewelers who create custom designs, offer jewelry repair, estate appraisals, and gems.